(561) 935-9763
Maura Curran, Attorney
Jupiter, FL 33458

Half of the Question

A living will is one of the most common documents people sign. It’s also one of the most misunderstood. Most people who have one believe it covers their medical decisions. It doesn’t.

A living will answers one question: whether you want life support started, continued, or removed if you have a terminal condition, an end-stage condition, or are in a persistent vegetative state. It can name the agent who carries out those wishes. But it speaks only to life support.

Picture a retired teacher in Jupiter. Divorced. Her son lives in Denver, her daughter in Atlanta. Years ago she signed a living will, and it’s still in a manila folder in her desk drawer, right under the manual for a dishwasher she no longer owns.

One morning she has a stroke. She survives it. She’s stable. She just can’t speak for herself for a while.

The questions start right away, and none of them are about life support, whether she goes to rehab or a skilled nursing facility. Whether she consents to a procedure her doctors recommend. Who signs the forms?

Her living will has nothing to say. She isn’t dying. She just needs someone to decide. And she never signed the document that names that person.

So the hospital turns to Florida’s default list. Her adult children are on it, and when there’s more than one, the decision goes to a majority of them.

Two children. Two time zones. Her son wants the rehab center near her house. Her daughter wants her moved closer to Atlanta. One to one isn’t a majority.

That’s when it goes to court. A petition is filed, a hearing is held, and a judge appoints a guardian to make her medical decisions. Once appointed, that guardian is first in line, ahead of both her children.

Most times, the guardian is someone she has never met. A professional appointed by the court, making decisions about her care and her treatment based on a file. All for a question she could have answered herself, years ago, in one afternoon.

The document that answers it is a health care surrogate designation. It names your agent: the person who talks to the doctors, receives your medical information, and makes medical decisions for you when you can’t. The everyday ones and the hard ones. You can name an alternate, too. It’s signed in front of two adult witnesses, and the person you name can’t be one of them.

Two documents, two different jobs. The living will covers one thing: life support. The health care surrogate designation covers every other medical decision.

People sign one of them and believe they’ve handled the whole question. They’ve handled half of it.

Choosing who speaks for you isn’t paperwork. It’s the difference between someone who knows you and a stranger with a file.

If you have a living will in a drawer and no one named to make your medical decisions, that’s the right place to start.

The Curran Law Firm handles estate planning and trust administration in Jupiter, Florida. We make sure the person you choose is the one with the authority to speak for you, not someone a court picks later.

Call 561-935-9763 to schedule your appointment.